Which is a valid basis to choose venue in NY?

Which is a valid basis to choose venue in NY?

• A. If no residence, π chooses
• B. County where real estate in question is located
• C. Where either Party resides
• D. All of the above

Answer: (A)

In New York, venue is tied to where the parties reside or where the action arose, with a special rule for real property actions. For disputes involving real estate, the proper venue is the county where the property is located. For other actions, the starting point is the residence of either party, but if neither party has a residence in New York, there is a rule that allows the plaintiff to choose the venue. This ensures there’s a workable path to filing even when there’s no tie to a specific county. The option tied to the real property location is only applicable to real property cases, not to every kind of action, and the option about either party’s residence presupposes that such a residence exists. Therefore, the valid basis that applies when there is no residence is that the plaintiff may choose the venue.

In New York, venue is tied to where the parties reside or where the action arose, with a special rule for real property actions. For disputes involving real estate, the proper venue is the county where the property is located. For other actions, the starting point is the residence of either party, but if neither party has a residence in New York, there is a rule that allows the plaintiff to choose the venue. This ensures there’s a workable path to filing even when there’s no tie to a specific county. The option tied to the real property location is only applicable to real property cases, not to every kind of action, and the option about either party’s residence presupposes that such a residence exists. Therefore, the valid basis that applies when there is no residence is that the plaintiff may choose the venue.